Fall Book Reviews
1.) One-In-A-Million Boy by Monica Wood
I think I am jaded right now. I just want a sweeping saga that takes me on a fantastic journey and entertains me for several days. This book isn't that... but... it is sweet and beautiful and intelligent. I am having such a hard time finding books that I LOVE. So far this year I have only found books that were *good* or *okay*. This is another one of the *good* books. I loved the relationships and unexpected friendships that were formed and the healing that takes place.
From Goodreads:
The incandescent story of a 104-year-old woman and the sweet, strange young boy assigned to help her around the house — a friendship that touches each member of the boy's unmoored family. For seven Saturdays, Quinn does yard work for Ona Vitkus, the wily 104-year-old Lithuanian immigrant the boy had visited weekly. Quinn soon discovers that the boy had talked Ona into gunning for the world record for Oldest Licensed Driver — and that's the least of her secrets. Despite himself, Quinn picks up where the boy left off, forging a friendship with Ona that allows him to know the son he never understood, a boy who was always listening, always learning. The One-in-a-Million Boy is a richly layered novel of hearts broken seemingly beyond repair and then bound by a stunning act of human devotion.
Ona is a fantastic character and I wanted more of her and "the boy" and less of Quinn and Belle, their struggles, and Quinn's music career woes. I thought the interactions between Ona and the little boy scout were magical and I wish that the whole book was just about the two of them. Still, this is a thoughtful and beautiful book. Perfect for a book club to discuss.
My Rating: Good. A sweet and thoughtful tale of unlikely friendship.
2.) The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton
From Goodreads:
Winner of the 1921 Pulitzer Prize, The Age of Innocence is Edith Wharton’s masterful portrait of desire and betrayal during the sumptuous Golden Age of Old New York, a time when society people “dreaded scandal more than disease.” This is Newland Archer’s world as he prepares to marry the beautiful but conventional May Welland. But when the mysterious Countess Ellen Olenska returns to New York after a disastrous marriage, Archer falls deeply in love with her. Torn between duty and passion, Archer struggles to make a decision that will either courageously define his life—or mercilessly destroy it.
I didn't love
The Age of Innocence but I did appreciate it. The story is subtle and restrained. There is little action and the drama lies in the small moments of the novel. On one level it is the story of unrequited love and on another level it is the story of late 1800s America in transition from a more traditional way of life to a more modern. The symbolism is rich and multilayered. I think I would have liked the book better if I felt more of a connection with the characters. I wish I liked them more....indecisive Newland, sheltered May, and the avant garde Countess Olenska. Their love triangle was frustrating and lackluster. I am sure it is due to my lack of connection with them. But the writing, on the other hand, now that is beautiful and delicate and nuanced. The glimpse into the world of upper class New York City in the 1870s with its unrelenting societal etiquette, conformity, and hypocrisy was fascinating despite a rather disappointing ending.
My Rating: Okay...but was hoping for more.
3.) Of Mess and Moxie by Jen Hatmaker
I absolutely loved Jen Hatmaker's last book
For the Love. It was awesome and a great introduction into the personality and persona of Jen Hatmaker. I now follow her on social media and listen to her podcast. I find her funny and insightful. I was looking forward to reading her new book,
Of Mess and Moxie, and anxiously awaited its release.
From Goodreads:
Jen Hatmaker, beloved author, Big Sister Emeritus, and Chief BFF, offers another round of hilarious tales, frank honesty, and hope for the woman who has forgotten her moxie. Whether discussing the grapple with change ("Everyone, be into this thing I'm into! Except when I'm not. Then everyone be cool.") or the time she drove to the wrong city for a fourth-grade field trip ("Why are we in San Antonio?"), Jen parlays her own triumphs and tragedies into a sigh of relief for all normal, fierce women everywhere who, like her, sometimes hide in the car eating crackers but also want to get back up and get back out, to live undaunted "in the moment" no matter what the moments hold.
If you liked
For the Love you will like
Of Mess and Moxie although I will say that
For the Love remains my favorite Hatmaker book. This book is both parts hilariously funny and seriously spiritual and I enjoyed both. I appreciate Hatmaker's outlook on life, marriage, parenting, Christianity, and community. My favorite sections are the ones discussing marriage and parenting teenagers and young adults. She is a soul sister!! I also loved her letter to her parents!! So funny and so true.
Yes, this is a book written by a Christian author and talks a lot about Jesus but in a way that is so encouraging and refreshing. Hatmaker lacks any pretense at being "perfect" in any way...and her vulnerability and her own "me too" is appreciated. Plus...it is also very funny and talks equally if not more about nonreligious subjects as well.
Some of my favorite quotes (hard to pick because there are so many gems)
On church:
"People may hate us because of Jesus, but they should never hate Jesus because of us. The way we treat others should lead them to only one conclusion: “If this is how Jesus loves, then I’m in.”
On the lack of civil discourse in society and social media:
“Love refuses to deny or dismantle another’s perspective simply because I don’t share it.”
On parenting teens:
"Parent Sex: delighting teens worldwide. Like I always tell our kids, after this many years, just be glad your parents still have sex and like each other. This comforts them zero percent."
I really liked it. I find Jen Hatmaker refreshing, relatable, and encouraging. It is a fast and engaging read.
My Rating: Good.
4.) Prayers For Sale by Sandra Dallas
This was our book club selection for October. I knew absolutely nothing about the book or author when I started reading it. I was surprised at how quickly I was drawn into the story and the interesting life of Hennie Comfort, an 87 year old woman, from a gold mining town in Colorado in the 1930s.
From Goodreads:
Hennie Comfort is eighty-six and has lived in the mountains of Middle Swan, Colorado since before it was Colorado. Nit Spindle is just seventeen and newly married. She and her husband have just moved to the high country in search of work. It's 1936 and the depression has ravaged the country and Nit and her husband have suffered greatly. Hennie notices the young woman loitering near the old sign outside of her house that promises "Prayers For Sale". Hennie doesn't sell prayers, never has, but there's something about the young woman that she's drawn to. The harsh conditions of life that each have endured create an instant bond and an unlikely friendship is formed, one in which the deepest of hardships are shared and the darkest of secrets are confessed.
Our book club enjoyed the book. I did too. My take away was the importance of friendship. Particularly unlikely friendships. Hennie is an elderly woman and Nit is a teenager and yet they find common ground and build a wonderful friendship. I know the importance of having friends who are in different stages of life than I am and all that I learn from them. I love that this was celebrated. I know that I have been blessed by friends who are older than me and how their wisdom, guidance, and friendship have benefited me. I have also learned much from my younger friends. I need them all and appreciate the way that they help me do life. The book is also a love letter to quilting and how quilting brought women together and strengthened and bonded them as they made beautiful items to warm their families.
I liked the book and read it quickly although I did think that there were a few too many *coincidences* in the book especially after Hennie moved clear across the country to a remote mining town. I had to suspend my disbelief a few times. I also saw the "twist" coming early on. But the story is a good one of friendship, service, forgiveness, redemption, and enduring to the end. I wish that we would have gotten more of the story of Jake and Hennie. I wanted to know more about their life together. But in the end, I really admired Hennie and felt inspired to reach out to and befriend more women who are younger than I am and also to reach out to and befriend more women who are further down the road of life than I am. We all need each other. I also was really inspired by the wonderful example of service that Hennie was to the families in her community.
My only complaint was that there wasn't much action...the plot was just a device to get Hennie to another location so that she could tell another story. While I enjoyed the stories I would've liked a bit more action and for a little more character development for some of the secondary characters. I did learn at book club that the author has written several other books and many of the same characters make appearances and probably are fleshed out a bit more as it sounds like some of her other novels tell their stories. I will most likely read more by this author.
My Rating: Good
5.) A Land More Kind Than Home By Wiley Cash
Every year, my town, chooses a book to read and discuss. This is done through the local library system and local bookstores. It's called
Spokane Is Reading. Then in the fall the author comes to town to discuss their book and to do a reading. It is awesome! I look forward to this every year. The books are always diverse and interesting. I love it!! This was the 2017 pick. It is described as a southern Gothic novel. I was excited to start reading.
From Goodreads:
A mesmerizing literary thriller about the bond between two brothers and the evil they face in a small western North Carolina town. For a curious boy like Jess Hall, growing up in Marshall means trouble when your mother catches you spying on grown-ups. Adventurous and precocious, Jess is enormously protective of his older brother, Christopher, a mute whom everyone calls Stump. Though their mother has warned them not to snoop, Stump can't help sneaking a look at something he's not supposed to - an act that will have catastrophic repercussions, shattering both his world and Jess's. It's a wrenching event that thrusts Jess into an adulthood for which he's not prepared. While there is much about the world that still confuses him, he now knows that a new understanding can bring not only a growing danger and evil - but also the possibility of freedom and deliverance as well.
I love a good dark southern novel and this was just that. Evil arrives in a small isolated town in North Carolina in the person of Carson Chambliss a preacher and religious zealot. A tragic death occurs and a mystery is unleashed. This novel is described as a thriller but I wouldn't necessarily call it that although it is dark and sinister and there were some parts that had me scared for different characters. In this novel, a young boy sees something that he shouldn't and events are set in motion. I was drawn right into the characters, setting, and story which is told by three different narrators with three very different perspectives and voices. It was atmospheric and sad and yet there was hope, forgiveness, and a kind of redemption.
I attended the event where Wiley Cash spoke about this novel...OH.MY.GOSH. He was fantastic!! I loved hearing him speak about the book, the characters, his background, how this novel came about, and his other books. He was so funny and down to earth. If you ever get the chance to hear him speak...GO. You will love him!
My Rating: Good! I loved the writing and the voice.
6.) A Room with a View by E.M. Forster
For the past two years I have made it a yearly goal to always be reading a classic in addition to whatever else I am also reading. I don't worry about how long it takes to finish it. I just slowly and steadily work my way through it. I have read so many wonderful classic novels over the past two years and now my goal has become a habit and one that I thoroughly enjoy. This was one of those books.
From Goodreads:
Lucy has her rigid, middle-class life mapped out for her until she visits Florence with her uptight cousin Charlotte, and finds her neatly ordered existence thrown off balance. Her eyes are opened by the unconventional characters she meets at the Pension Bertolini: flamboyant romantic novelist Eleanor Lavish, the Cockney Signora, curious Mr Emerson and, most of all, his passionate son George.
Lucy finds herself torn between the intensity of life in Italy and the repressed morals of Edwardian England, personified in her terminally dull fiancé Cecil Vyse. Will she ever learn to follow her own heart?
A sheltered young Englishwoman goes abroad to Italy and meets a colorful cast of characters and begins to see life in a different light after gaining some experience and independence. Her eyes become open to what life is really about. She returns to England and finds it difficult to yield to the demands of society after her awakening in Italy.
I enjoyed this novel with its humorous cast of quirky characters...the charming Lucy, the brooding and unconventional George, the pesky younger brother Freddy, the pretentious and controlling Cecil, and the irritating spinster cousin and chaperone Charlotte. This was a quick and enjoyable read. It was my first Forster novel and I am looking forward to moving on to
Howards End.
My Rating: Good. A charming and quick read.
7.) As You Wish by Cary Elwes
Growing up in the 80s I absolutely loved The Princess Bride. It was one of my all-time favorite movies. I've watched it at least a hundred times. This was a movie that was oft-quoted by me and my friends growing up. It also became a movie that was special to my extended family. Every year on the last night of our family reunion at the lake, all of us cousins would sleep on the floor in the living room, and watch The Princess Bride. It was our tradition. And then there was Cary Elwes...oh my gosh...I have been a big fan since the movie Lady Jane. Everything about this movie evokes such great childhood memories. I was super excited to read this book...written by Cary Elwes himself.. and to learn more about the making of such a great movie.
From Goodreads:
From actor Cary Elwes, who played the iconic role of Westley in The Princess Bride, comes a first-person account and behind-the-scenes look at the making of the cult classic film filled with never-before-told stories, exclusive photographs, and interviews with costars Robin Wright, Wallace Shawn, Billy Crystal, Christopher Guest, and Mandy Patinkin, as well as author and screenwriter William Goldman, producer Norman Lear, and director Rob Reiner.
Did I love it as much as I was hoping to? No, but I did like it. Maybe I'm just not that into books about how movies are made. It's possible. I did enjoy the behind the scenes look at how the movie came to be, how the actors were cast, and the friendships that were made. That said, I found some of it a bit on the slow and tedious side. Too many movie making details. More than I ever wanted to know. I guess I was just more interested in the people and less in the filmaking. I loved reading about the friendship between Andre the Giant and Cary Elwes. He goes into quite a bit of detail about this unique friendship but not in as much depth about his friendships with other cast members; although it is obvious that they all had a special relationship, and a cherished experience making this movie. It created a bond that has lasted for over 25 years. I just wanted a little bit more.
Other readers/reviewers HIGHLY recommend the audiobook version. I wish that I would've experienced the book that way. It is narrated by Cary Elwes and by several of the cast and crew from the movie. I think this would be a great road trip audiobook for a family. I am always on the lookout for books that my whole family can enjoy listening to in the car. This would be a great one.
My Rating: Good-ish
Die Hard Princess Bride Fans will love it... but be prepared to wade through a lot of tedious movie making details.
8.) Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
I put this book off for a long while. First, it is in play format. Ugh. Second, I want pure J.K. Rowling not glorified fan fiction with her stamp of approval on it. As much as I wanted the world of Harry Potter to continue I knew that this book would ultimately be somewhat of a letdown. It was.
From Goodreads:
Based on an original new story by J.K. Rowling, Jack Thorne and John Tiffany, a new play by Jack Thorne, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is the eighth story in the Harry Potter series and the first official Harry Potter story to be presented on stage.
The story takes place nineteen years after Deathly Hallows. Harry Potter works for the Ministry of Magic and his youngest son Albus Severus Potter is about to go off to attend Hogwarts. This book made me realize just how much I miss the world of Harry Potter. I love this universe with its beloved characters, places, witchcraft and wizardry, and of course Hogwarts. The small bit that we are given in this book/play was wonderful but at the same time it made me realize that you can't go home again.
There were some parts of the book/play or whatever you want to call it that I just loved...seeing old friends, Harry talking to Dumbledore's portrait, seeing Snape again, and a few other scenes. But it also lacked in many ways too. The magic was missing. Oh spells were cast and potions were made but the magic of this world and Rowling's writing about these beloved characters was noticeably lacking. I missed the humor and the relationships and the way that these books made you think and feel. Instead of feeling magic and wonder I felt angst. Plus, where were the rest of the Weaselys? Teddy? Hagrid? I felt removed from the characters and the story. I am sure that probably comes from reading the play rather than watching it...but still. I loved the nostalgia. I was happy to see familiar faces and revisit familiar places but ultimately I was let down.
My Rating: So-So