Thursday, May 24, 2007

Book Review # 7 (A little late in coming)









I was very excited to read this book. As a psych major I was intrigued by its subject matter:



"Blink is a book about how we think without thinking, about choices that seem to be made in an instant--in the blink of an eye--that actually aren't as simple as they seem...Blink reveals that great decision makers aren't those who process the most information or spend the most time deliberating, but those who have perfected the art of "thin-slicing"--filtering the very few factors that matter from an overwhelming number of variables".



Hum...the unconscious, cognitive processes, split-second decision making, thin-slicing...being the psychology geek that I am...that stuff is right up my alley. I was so excited to get this book and begin reading. Then I got the book and began reading. The first chapter was great...unfortunately it all went down hill from there.



I think my friend, Lucy, summed it up best when she said:


"Basically, I think the author took a neat idea (we can make really good decisions in less than two seconds), did a little scientific research to back up his claim, and then beat a dead horse into the ground."



I found this book to be torturous. Torturous like when you have signed up for a class in college and you are really excited about it and then it turns out to be nothing like you thought and with a very lame professor to boot. That is what Blink was to me. It was like reading a psych textbook...for dummies. This whole book could have been an interesting article in a psychology journal but I felt like the author was stretching, and stretching, and stretching it out to be book length...and boy could I feel the STRETCHING!!



There were some interesting things in it...such as:



1.) A study was done on how to find out if someone would be a good employee...the study consisted of one group that met the prospective employees for lunches and dinners regularly for a year and spent time asking them all kinds of questions and the other group that dropped by their houses and looked around for 15 minutes...guess which group was better at judging whether or not someone would be a good employee? Yep...the 15 minute group. They were able to assess things like conscientiousness, open-mindedness, emotional stability etc. According to this study our personal belongings/living environment contain a wealth of very telling information.



-This study justified my inner snoop. I love people watching, blog reading, seeing how other people live, what they buy at the grocery store, looking at people's Ipod playlist, finding out what their top 5 favorite books are...WHY...because I believe it contains a wealth of information about them...and I guess I was right. Guess what one of our YW activities is next month..."Room Tour". We will go to each girls house and see their rooms and things that are important to them...coincidence? I don't think so.



2.) That being tall is an advantage in the business world and life in general. Interesting statistic according to the book : "In the US population , about 14.5 percent of all men are six feet or taller. Even more striking, in the general American population, 3.9 percent of adult men are six foot two or taller".



-That is CRAZY! Tall men ARE hard to come by. The average American male is 5 ft 9. When I shared this finding with my husband (6ft2) and my brother (6ft4) they felt supremely manly and spent the day strutting around lording their height over all the smaller men they came in contact with.



-Next interesting fact: The author polled CEOs of Fortune 500 companies and found that while the majority of CEOs are white males (we won't go into the injustice to women that is :) 58% of them were 6 feet and over and almost a third were 6 ft 2 or taller. And...through all kinds of boring studies researchers have found that an inch of height is worth almost $789 a year in salary. The book says : "That means that a person who is 6 feet tall but otherwise identical to someone who is five foot five will make on average $5,525 more per year".



3.) I found the section on Improv comedy fascinating. It was interesting to learn that improv isn't random or chaotic..."It is an art form governed by a series of rules" and those rules must be abided. The spontaneity isn't random.


-"One of the most important rules that makes improv possible...is the idea of agreement, the notion that a very simple way to create a story--or humor--is to have characters accept everything that happens to them". So basically when an idea is yelled out to an improv group they have to accept it and so does the rest of the group and then whatever a member of the improv group says the rest of the members have to accept...if they don't it doesn't work and isn't funny. After I read this I watched an improv show and low and behold it was actually true.


There were a couple of other topics that were interesting...the part about the Pepsi Challenge and the disaster of New Coke. I also liked the section where the author talked about how children from abusive homes are very good at thin-slicing and the art of "mind reading"...from years of learning in an instant from body language etc. how to judge a situation.


So there were some interesting topics but presented in such a mind-numbing fashion I wanted to scream!! Beat a dead horse is right! If I had to listen to the author bring up that stinking art museum and it's fake statue one more time I was going to lose my mind.


Book Review: SO-SO with a side of dull and mind-numbing...I'd skip it...I've just given you the highlights anyway! ;)

6 comments:

Stacey said...

Thank goodness John is 6'3!! Now...show me the money!! Hope you are having a good day--XOXO Stacey

carlo said...

thanks for the highlights. i won't add it to my list! :)

Lucy said...

You did a much better review. Because the highlights are interesting. But such a boring book. I totally agree about the pscyhology textbook similarity. Except..not quite as well thought out.

I just thin sliced your blog and think it's fantastic!:)

[alisar] said...

I'm so ashamed...so ashamed! I selected "Blink" and no one liked it. At least we didn't waste any time at book group actually TALKING about it! So sorry. I was absolutely fascinated with the idea, but I can see what you and Lucy meant about a dead horse. I will eventually write a review too, I think mine will be a little softer, more forgiving of the tedium, mostly because I have a simple brain that finds comfort in hearing things over and over and over...

Kelly said...

Do you know that annoying tune "this is the book that never ends, it goes on and on my friend..."

I read this a few months ago and got the same out of it that you did. The first few pages had me, the rest of the book was more of the same.

Oh well, they can't all be Scottish time travelers with nipples.

Rebecca said...

I will admit it, I am one of those people who won't finish a book if I'm not enjoying it. And I wasn't enjoying Blink, so I didn't finish it (sorry Alisa, I like you!)

I did learn though that being a 5'-3" tall woman, does not give me an advantage in the work force. I'm so glad that I am valued, no matter how tall, where I do work, at home:)