Two Book Reviews
I guess I shouldn't call these book reviews. This will be more like an extension of my book journal. I have kept a book journal for years. I like to know what I have read , what I liked, and what I didn't like. I have a rating system. It's more like a movie review rating system. The categories are Fabulous (the highest...a rare rating), Excellent, Good, OK, and Hated It. Not that eloquent but it's worked for me over the years. So onto the reviews:

The first is Chocolat by Joanne Harris. This book was given to me by Rebecca at our book club Christmas party book exchange. I was very excited to get it because I have been wanting to read it for a long time. I am a Francophile (I think that's the word) I love all things French. I took French in High School and at BYU. I have always wanted to go to France. I like French food. You get the idea. This book was a great armchair travel book. It takes place in a small village in France. It is filled with quirky, colorful, beret-wearing characters. The main character is a woman named Vianne. She and her small daughter come to a small rural village to start a new life. She opens a chocolate shop, charms the villagers, and ends up setting herself at odds with the local priest of the Catholic Church. He feels that she is decadence personified to say the least. Oh--did I mention that Vianne might have magical powers?? The plot thickens...or should I say the chocolate thickens!! Do not read this book if you are trying to lose weight. You will CRAVE chocolate!! Chocolate is truly the main character of this book. Thank goodness I read it when I was sick and nauseous. But even that didn't stop the chocolate craving. I roused myself from my sick bed and staggered into the kitchen to scarf down some Valentines candy. Did it taste good? No! Did I feel worse? Yes! But I was powerless against the subliminal--ok maybe not subliminal--very overt message to EAT CHOCOLATE NOW!! This was a book that left me warm and cozy. I felt like I had gone on a small jaunt to France and interacted with the local color.
There were just a couple of things that I didn't like. There were three different story lines that I felt would've been really interesting to explore and would've given the book a few interesting twists. These story lines were mentioned and then dropped. That was too bad. But all in all I rate it Good. Actually VERY GOOD! A twist or turn would've given it an Excellent rating. But I really liked the book and recommend it to anyone who loves France, chocolate, and cozy reads. Thanks Rebecca!
P.S. I have never seen the movie so I don't know how it compares.

The next review is for Angle of Repose by Wallace Stegner. This was our latest book club read for the month of February. It is a beautifully written, eloquent, descriptive book. It has been highly, highly recommended to me by several people...readers who I respect. Most of them have said that it was the best book they have ever read. Wow! That is saying a lot. This book is a very long and epic tale of a husband and wife who move to the west in the late 1800's to settle. This was good news to me. I love long, fat, epic, historical fiction...and it was. It is told through the research of the this couple's grandson, Lyman Ward, a historian, who is now in his fifties and handicapped. He begins to research his grandmother's life for a book he is writing. A lot of the story is told through letters that were sent between his grandmother, Susan, and her best friend, Augusta. It is a story of the marriage of Susan and Oliver and the hardships, joys, and disappointments they experienced with a backdrop of the scenic west...California, Mexico, Colorado, and Idaho.
This is a Pulitzer Prize winning book. The writing is beyond beautiful. Stegner reminds me a bit of Steinbeck. I really liked this book...was it the best book I have ever read? No. But it was certainly one of the most beautifully written books I have ever read. I love the way the story unfolds...letters, documents, flipping time periods (the late 1800's and the 1970's). Stegner doesn't sugar coat the characters. They aren't larger than life. They are human and not always sympathetic. I found myself disliking Lyman, Susan, and Oliver at different times thorough out the book but I grew to care about each of them.
I rate this as Excellent for the writing alone. I was a bit disappointed with the ending. I felt like I had invested a lot and was some what let down and wanted to know more but that would've added another 500 pages to the book!!

3 comments:
I like the idea of your reading journal and the ratings. I remember I read Chocolat a long time ago and see, if I had kept a journal I would have remembered exactly what I thought of it. I do remember the chocolate part for sure!
I was having a hard time getting through Angle of Repose. Not because I didn't like it, but because I needed to concentrate while reading it and I needed quiet time away from the kids to do it. So I was up until 2am last night finishing it. It broke my heart. I think maybe I am too sensitive, but Agnes, Frank, Susan, Oliver, and Ollie and forgiveness! So tragic! I was crying, trying to be quiet while my family slept. Maybe it was because I was tired, but I wept for a while before falling asleep. It also reminded me of Steinbeck, at least in the way I am affected by his writing.
Rebecca's comment is why this book is ONE of my favorites. It breaks your heart. There are lots of books that make you feel sad or glad or whatever, but this book was tough with the raw emotions it made me feel. I read a lot of books and honestly forget most of them. I can kind of remember the story if someone reminds me. But this has stuck with me for months now. It tradgedy, courage, frustration, humiliation, redemption....have all stuck with me. I think that's why it's a great book. I don't know how Stegner did it but he created something real.
Post a Comment